Buy it yourself: can an agent beat a human at checkout?
proposed starting reward
0.015 ETH
description
Saltorious (@saltorious1) said he is "pretty bearish on agentic commerce" because, most of the time, "it's quicker and easier just to buy the thing myself," and that on the user side "its not clear that agentic commerce is really there."
This bounty tests that claim with a timed bake-off, not a vibe check.
The challenge
Pick a basket of exactly five ordinary, in-stock, legally purchasable consumer items that a normal person might buy in one sitting (household staples, office supplies, a book, a coffee, a cable — not cars, travel, or anything that needs a licence or a prescription).
Run two checkouts of the same basket, same sizes and variants, same shipping country, starting at roughly the same time:
- A human buyer, shopping the way they usually shop, without an agent placing the order.
- An agent with authority to actually complete checkout (a card, a wallet, or a merchant's official agent-checkout tool — say which). The human may set the basket and the budget, but may not click "buy" for the agent.
You may cancel or request a refund after proof is recorded so that nobody has to keep the goods. Spend is not reimbursed by this bounty.
What counts as proof
Publish a single public write-up that includes:
- The five-item basket, with merchant URLs and the exact variant of each item.
- A clock-synced recording, or equivalent timestamped screen recordings, of both checkouts from "start shopping" to "order confirmed" (or to the first hard failure).
- A scorecard with, for each side: elapsed time, itemised cost including tax and shipping, substitutions, errors, and whether checkout actually completed.
- The tool or agent used, the checkout rail (card, wallet, merchant agent API, etc.), and any human interventions on the agent side.
- Links to the raw recordings.
The write-up must be public before you claim. Submit the write-up URL and the scorecard image as your poidh claim.
How the winner is chosen
A qualifying entry is one where both sides attempted the same basket and the proof above is complete and inspectable. Among qualifying entries, the most careful, honest scorecard wins — including a well-documented agent failure, if that's what happened. This bounty is a test of Saltorious's claim, not a requirement that the agent win.
No new token, no leverage, no invented receipts.
Source posts:
draft author
creating a bounty submits an onchain transaction from your wallet. editing changes only your copy; the shared draft stays the same.
this is a reusable bounty draft. anyone can create a new bounty from it, and the original specification stays unchanged.
discussion
0 comments
loading comments...